I
| 610 | I Am David | PG |
| 1332 | I Am Legend | PG-13 |
| 1861 | I Am Number Four | PG-13 |
| 1630 | I Can Do Bad All by Myself | PG-13 |
| 403 | I Capture the Castle | R |
| 2060 | I Have Tourette’s But Tourette’s Doesn’t Have Me (Free Use) | G |
| 1594 | I Love You, Beth Cooper | PG-13 |
| 1570 | I Love You, Man | R |
| 1249 | I Now Pronounce You Chuck & Larry | PG-13 |
| 2286 | I, Frankenstein | PG-13 |
| 538 | I, Robot | PG-13 |
| 1359 | I’m Not There | R |
| 251 | Ice Age | PG |
| 2082 | Ice Age: Continental Drift | PG-13 |
| 1596 | Ice Age: Dawn of the Dinosaurs | PG |
| 866 | Ice Age: The Meltdown | PG |
| 647 | Ice Princess | G |
| 360 | Identity | R |
| 2151 | Identity Thief | R |
| 2368 | If I Stay | PG-13 |
| 286 | Igby Goes Down | R |
| 1479 | IGOR | PG |
| 1930 | I’ll Remember April | PG |
| 2455 | I’ll See You In My Dreams | PG-13 |
| 2406 | Illinois Terminal (Free Use) | PG |
| 896 | Illusionist, The | PG-13 |
| 1684 | Imaginarium of Doctor Parnassus | PG-13 |
| 1607 | Imagine That | PG |
| 2417 | Imitation Game, The | PG-13 |
| 1962 | Immortals | R |
| 246 | Importance of Being Earnest, The | PG |
| 2136 | Impossible, The | PG-13 |
| 465 | In America | PG-13 |
| 1383 | In Bruges | R |
| 732 | In Her Shoes | PG-13 |
| 216 | In the Bedroom | R |
| 1316 | In the Shadow of the Moon | PG |
| 1326 | In the Valley of Elah | R |
| 1800 | Inception | PG-13 |
| 873 | Inconvenient Truth (Free Use) | PG |
| 2164 | Incredible Burt Wonderstone, The | PG-13 |
| 1432 | Incredible Hulk, The | PG-13 |
| 591 | Incredibles, The | PG |
| 1430 | Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull | PG-13 |
| 994 | Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade | PG-13 |
| 992 | Indiana Jones and the Raiders of the Lost Ark | PG |
| 993 | Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom | PG |
| 1123 | Infamous | R |
| 1652 | Informant!, The | R |
| 1620 | Inglourious Basterds | R |
| 1554 | Inkheart | PG |
| 826 | Inside Man | R |
| 2474 | Inside Out | PG |
| 1824 | Inside the Milky Way (Free Use) | G |
| 1881 | Insidious | PG-13 |
| 2238 | Insidious: Chapter 2 | PG-13 |
| 2462 | Insidious: Chapter 3 | PG-13 |
| 237 | Insomnia | R |
| 2448 | Insurgent | PG-13 |
| 1549 | International, The | R |
| 2418 | Interstellar | PG-13 |
| 686 | Into the West | PG |
| 1321 | Into The Wild | R |
| 2413 | Into the Woods | PG |
| 428 | Intolerable Cruelty | PG-13 |
| 1296 | Invasion, The | PG-13 |
| 1045 | Inventing the Abbotts | R |
| 1635 | Invention of Lying, The | PG-13 |
| 1695 | Invictus | PG-13 |
| 886 | Invincible | PG |
| 206 | Iris | R |
| 1018 | Iron Giant, The | PG |
| 1973 | Iron Lady, The | PG-13 |
| 1424 | Iron Man | PG-13 |
| 1770 | Iron Man 2 | PG-13 |
| 2204 | Iron Man 3 | PG-13 |
| 1609 | Is Anybody There? | PG-13 |
| 706 | Island, The | PG-13 |
| 308 | I-Spy | PG-13 |
| 2443 | It Follows | R |
| 380 | It Runs in the Family | PG-13 |
| 536 | It’s a Wonderful Life | G |
| 1685 | It’s Complicated | R |
| 378 | Italian Job, The | PG-13 |
| 1826 | It’s Kind of a Funny Story | PG-13 |
| 1008 | It’s the Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown | G |
Heyworth Public Library District 